The shocking $19.95 U-Haul truck rental secret

The Hidden Costs of Moving: A Closer Look at U-Haul’s Pricing Tactics

We write stories that make you richer. Take a second right now: Follow us and get tips that will change your life.

For over 30 years, I’ve been writing about money, and one thing has remained consistent: corporate America’s fondness for hidden fees. These charges are often buried in the fine print, making it difficult for consumers to understand the true cost of a product or service. One prime example is U-Haul, a moving company that has drawn attention for its deceptive pricing strategies.

The Illusion of the $20 Truck

You might have seen a U-Haul truck with “19.95” painted on the side, and thought it was an affordable option for moving across town. However, this low price is just a hook to attract customers. According to consumer watchdogs at Truth in Advertising, it’s nearly impossible for anyone in the country to rent a truck for that advertised price. The organization recently filed a complaint with New York City officials, arguing that U-Haul uses a drip-pricing scheme—advertising only part of a product’s price and revealing additional charges later—to inflate its bills.

Hidden Charges That Add Up

When you reserve a truck for $19.95, the meter starts running in ways you might not expect. The consumer group highlights that U-Haul adds an environmental fee and a vehicle cost recovery fee to every rental nationwide. If you’re renting in New York City, it gets even worse. Certain locations charge a mandatory facility fee that can reach up to $15.95. These hidden charges can increase the base cost of your rental by nearly $20 before you even drive off the lot. None of this is clearly disclosed until the very end of the online reservation process.

Additionally, there are tolls. If you drive through a tolled tunnel or over a bridge, U-Haul tacks on an administrative fee for processing that toll. This disproportionately affects drivers in major metro areas where tolls are unavoidable.

Taking Action Against Hidden Fees

New York City recently took action against these tactics. Earlier this year, Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed an executive order aimed at combating hidden junk fees, setting up a task force to crack down on deceptive pricing across the city.

How to Protect Your Wallet on Moving Day

While you might not be able to force a massive corporation to drop its fees, you can outsmart them. Here are some tips to keep your moving costs grounded:

• Read the final screen carefully: Before clicking confirm on any rental reservation, scrutinize the itemized list of charges. If you see facility fees or recovery charges you weren’t expecting, factor them into your actual budget.
• Budget for mileage and gas: The low advertised price never includes mileage or fuel. You’ll pay a per-mile rate that can add up quickly, plus you’ll need to return the truck with the exact same amount of gas it had when you picked it up.
• Compare the total, not the tease: Don’t just look at base rates when comparing U-Haul to competitors like Budget or Penske. Take a few minutes to run test reservations through all their websites to see who actually offers the cheapest out-the-door price.
• Beware the insurance upsell: The rental counter will always push you to buy their collision damage waiver. Check your personal auto insurance policy or the credit card you’re using to pay for the rental. You might already be covered, which means you can safely decline the expensive extra coverage.

Smart Investing Tips

Moving is stressful enough without feeling like you’ve been taken for a ride. Always assume the massive numbers in the advertisements are just the starting line, not the finish line.

How savvy investors double their retirement savings (Sponsored)

A Vanguard study found that, on average, a hypothetical $500,000 investment over 25 years would grow to $1.7 million if you manage it yourself, but more than $3.4 million if you work with a financial adviser. That’s twice as much!

If you’ve got $100,000 in investible assets, you qualify for a free appointment with a vetted financial advisor in your area.

Learn more

Please carefully review the methodologies employed in the Vanguard white paper, Putting a Value on your Value: Quantifying Vanguard Advisor’s Alpha.